Methodology library

Train methodology

Rail Emissions Model (REM)

SQUAKE

SQUAKE's own passenger rail method. For every trip it uses the most specific factor available, from an operator's published figure down to a global average, and shows which one it used.

Publisher
SQUAKE
Best for
International rail travel and booking tools
Result
One total per trip, for all travellers, in CO₂e
Energy scope
WTW
Factor year
Matched to the travel date
Greenhouse gases
CO₂e from the factor used for each trip

How it works

  • A known rail distance is used as it is. A route path is measured without a detour factor. A straight-line distance gets a detour factor for the train type, from 1.08 for high-speed trains to 1.33 for trams.
  • Route paths that cross borders are split by country, and each part gets the most specific factor available for that country.
  • Seat class adjusts the result: first class counts 1.4 times an average seat and second class 0.9 times.
  • Where REM models electricity itself, it uses the national grid average. Operator and national factors are used as published.
  • Each result shows the tier, the factor, and the operator, country and year that were matched.

Unit and greenhouse gases

  • Results are in CO₂e (carbon dioxide equivalent) per trip, for all travellers on it, in grams, kilograms or tonnes as requested.
  • CO₂e comes from the factor of the tier used for each trip: an operator's or a country's published figure, used as published, or REM's own energy model. Each result shows the tier and factor used.

The tiers

REM uses the first tier that has data for the trip, starting with the most specific. Tiers 1 to 5 are live and all use secondary data, including Tier 1. The ranges are indicative, not statistical confidence intervals.

  1. Tier 0: Route-specific data

    It will include Green Travel Data for journeys in Great Britain. SQUAKE is also exploring other operator-specific and route-specific sources.

    Coming soon
  2. Tier 1: Operator factor

    The operator's published figure for the service and year.

    ±10 to 20%
  3. Tier 2: Operator traction mix

    The operator's traction mix (for example electric and diesel), with shared energy assumptions.

    ±15 to 25%
  4. Tier 3: Country factor

    A published national factor for the rail category and year.

    ±15 to 30%
  5. Tier 4: Energy model

    Traction shares × energy use × emission factors, for planning and screening. Tends to overestimate.

    ±30 to 50%
  6. Tier 5: Global average

    Used when nothing more specific exists.

    ±50% or more

Trip details used

When a detail is missing, SQUAKE uses the default.

DetailDefaultNotes
Origin and destinationRequired without a distance or routeStations or addresses.
Rail distanceMeasured from the route path, or estimated from the stationsUsed as given.
Route pathNonePoints along the route, used to measure the distance in each country.
OperatorNoneNeeded for tiers 1 and 2.
Train typeAverageFor example high-speed, intercity, regional, commuter, tram or metro.
TractionDieselDiesel, electric, hydrogen or HVO. Only used to choose between operator figures and for the energy model tier.
Seat classAverageFirst, second or average.
Travel dateNoneMatches the factors to the travel year.
CountriesNoneUsed for the country tiers.
Number of travellers1

What is included

Included

  • Producing and supplying the energy, and running the train
  • Electricity for electric trains (the national grid average where REM models it)

Not included

  • Infrastructure, and building and maintaining trains
  • Refrigerant leaks and diesel black carbon

Limitations

  • Results are estimates from the factor of the tier used. They are not a measurement of the actual emissions of an individual train journey.
  • Results are only as specific as the best tier available for the trip.

GHG Protocol, CSRD and ESRS reporting

  • Scope 3: business train journeys belong in Scope 3, category 6 (business travel), of the GHG Protocol. ESRS E1 uses the GHG Protocol categories for Scope 3.
  • Boundary: the GHG Protocol's minimum boundary for business travel is the transport companies' own Scope 1 and 2 emissions: the fuel burned in the vehicles and the generation of the electricity they use. Producing and delivering fuel goes beyond that minimum, so say which energy scope your figure uses.
  • Unit: the GHG Protocol and ESRS report emissions in tonnes of CO₂e. Request results in tonnes, or divide kilograms by 1,000.
  • Global warming potentials: ESRS E1 asks for CO₂e based on the latest IPCC values over 100 years, currently those of the Sixth Assessment Report (AR6), and the GHG Protocol recommends the same. Operator and national factors use the values their publishers chose. Say which values your figures use.
  • Method: name the methodology, factor year and energy scope (WTW or TTW) next to the figure. Keep the same settings from year to year, or explain the change. The GHG Protocol asks you to describe the data sources, emission factors, global warming potentials, methods and assumptions behind each category.
  • Estimates: every REM tier uses secondary data, including operator figures in Tier 1, and each result shows the tier used. The tier ranges above give an indication of accuracy. The GHG Protocol asks for the share of emissions calculated with data from suppliers or other value chain partners, and ESRS asks companies to explain estimates, including their assumptions and how uncertain they are.
  • Credits and contributions: report the figure before any carbon credits or contributions. The GHG Protocol requires emissions to be reported independent of GHG trades such as carbon credits, and ESRS E1 also keeps credits out of the GHG figures. Report them separately.

Customer claims (EmpCo)

EU rules on environmental claims to consumers (Directive (EU) 2024/825, known as EmpCo) have applied since 27 September 2026.

  • Present results as estimates and name the methodology, for example with a link to this page.
  • If you compare train journeys by their emissions, for example in a booking tool, tell customers how the comparison works: the methodology, what is compared and how often the data are updated. EU rules treat this as material information. Calculate every option with the same methodology and settings so the comparison is fair.
  • Do not claim that a train journey is climate neutral, or has a reduced or positive climate impact, because of carbon credits. EU rules ban claims based on offsetting.
  • Describe contributions by what they fund, not as cancelling out the emissions of the train journey.
  • Avoid generic claims such as calling a train journey green or eco-friendly. Use specific statements, such as the figure and the methodology.

This section and the one above are general guidance, not legal advice.

Sources

  1. Rail Emissions Modelrailemissionsmodel.com

    Tiers, uncertainty, governance and assurance status.

  2. SQUAKE: Rail Emissions Model white papersquake.earth

    Request the full methodology (registration form).

  3. GHG Protocol: Scope 3 calculation guidanceghgprotocol.org

    Category 6 (business travel): what it covers and how to calculate it.

  4. GHG Protocol: Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standardghgprotocol.org

    What to report for each Scope 3 category, including data sources, the share of supplier data and biogenic CO₂.

  5. GHG Protocol: Global Warming Potential valuesghgprotocol.org

    100-year global warming potentials from the IPCC, with the latest (AR6) values recommended.

  6. European Commission: corporate sustainability reportingfinance.ec.europa.eu

    The CSRD and the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), including the 2026 revision.

  7. EUR-Lex: Directive (EU) 2024/825 (EmpCo)eur-lex.europa.eu

    EU rules against misleading environmental claims, applying since 27 September 2026.